Good idea. But is a poll needed as the criteria are very objective?
Perhaps we could just do a big audit and open issues on the respective github accounts?
Is the purpose of the poll to warn end users or the package developers?
I need to update all my apps to incorporate these best practices. I’ll do that before I code a new one…
Is there a way to run an automated test to check which criteria are present or not in an app?
to give to developers idea to improve their packages;
to give to users a better way to evaluate quality app than “working/inprogress/notworking” states.
Currently, there is a tools to check official apps on some point but not all. The tools needs some resource to check install/upgrade/remove scripts. For the moment, this tools is not used on unofficial apps. I don’t know if it is possible. https://dash.yunohost.org